FMCSA’s New Transparency Rule: What It Means for Your Next Car Shipment

• April 26, 2026

Last updated on April 26, 2026

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) has finalized a broker transparency rule requiring auto transport brokers to disclose how much they pay the carrier who actually moves your vehicle. The rule is designed to answer a question a lot of customers have been asking for years: where does my money actually go?

Here’s what the rule requires, when it kicks in, and what it means for you.

What the Rule Requires

Under the new FMCSA rule, auto transport brokers must now provide customers with documentation showing:

• The total price charged to the customer
• The amount paid to the carrier (the actual trucking company)
• The broker’s margin (the difference between the two)

This disclosure has to happen within a specific timeframe — brokers are required to provide the carrier payment information within 30 days of completed delivery, and must make it available upon request before booking in some circumstances.

The rule applies to brokers operating under FMCSA authority — which is essentially any company that matches vehicles with carriers but doesn’t own the trucks themselves.

Why This Rule Exists

The auto transport brokerage space has a transparency problem. A customer sees a quote of $1,200. The broker books a carrier for $700 and pockets $500. The customer has no idea.

That $500 margin isn’t inherently wrong — brokers provide real value, and everyone needs to make money. The problem is when the margin is so high that the carrier is being underpaid to move your car, which leads to delays, lower priority on the truck, and in some cases, carriers walking away from loads.

There’s also the issue of bait-and-switch quoting: a broker quotes low, wins the booking, then can’t find a carrier at that price and comes back asking for more. With mandatory disclosure, customers will have a clearer picture of whether that $800 quote was ever real.

What Transcar Discloses — and Has Been Disclosing

We’ve operated transparently on carrier payments since we started. Our pricing is built to pay carriers competitively — because carriers who get paid fairly show up on time, take better care of the vehicles they haul, and don’t walk away from loads.

Our carrier payout on a standard move typically runs 78-85% of the total customer price. The remaining 15-22% covers our operations: load board access, insurance, customer service, tracking coordination, and the work it takes to match your specific vehicle with a carrier who runs that exact route.

When the FMCSA rule kicks in, we’ll provide the disclosure paperwork. It will confirm what we’ve been telling customers verbally: we’re not taking half your money.

What to Ask Any Broker Before Booking

With or without the FMCSA rule fully in effect, you can ask these questions right now and a reputable broker should answer them:

“What percentage of my payment goes to the carrier?”

If the answer is vague or they change the subject, that tells you something.

“Is my carrier already assigned?”

Brokers who quote without a carrier locked are guessing at the price. The carrier assignment happens when the load is posted on the board. Some brokers quote before that and hope they can cover the rate later. That’s where you get the “the carrier needs more money” call the day before pickup.

“What’s your fuel surcharge, and is it included in this quote?”

At Transcar, the current fuel surcharge is 16% and it’s in your quote from day one.

“What happens if no carrier takes the load at this price?”

A good broker has a real answer — whether that’s adjusting the carrier rate, rebooking, or offering a refund. “We’ll figure it out” is not a real answer.

What This Doesn’t Fix

Disclosure rules help informed customers make better decisions. They don’t stop bad actors from operating in the space, and they don’t guarantee quality. A broker can disclose their margin and still book the cheapest possible carrier with a poor record.

The factors that actually matter: carrier vetting (do they have a good FMCSA safety rating?), insurance coverage on the vehicle while in transit, and communication throughout the move. Transparency rules don’t mandate quality — they just give you better information to evaluate brokers yourself.

We vet every carrier before booking. We don’t post loads to the board and accept whoever bids lowest. We have carrier relationships we’ve built over years, and we know which ones handle vehicles well on specific lanes.

The Bottom Line

The FMCSA transparency rule is good for customers and good for brokers who were already operating fairly. It will make it harder for low-ball, bait-and-switch brokers to hide the gap between what they quote and what they pay.

For anyone using Transcar: nothing changes in how we operate. You’ll get the disclosure paperwork when it’s required, and it’ll confirm what our pricing already shows.

—

Get a transparent quote for your vehicle shipment:

📞 (682) 252-4654

Or request a quote online: transcar.com/#quote

We’ll tell you your rate, our carrier payout structure, and who’s moving your car — before you book.